What you need to do?
You can earn this stamp in Chapter 1: Heartbreak – specifically the Devil variation: Devil Makes Everyone Miserable.
You’ll need to find something that even a ghost will find scary.
You may have tried to find somewhere else in the game to try and claim this stamp, but in actuality, it’s remarkably quick and easy to get it.
Once you know how, that is!
You only need 2 panels.
How to get the Spookier stamp in Storyteller
Panel 1
Begin with a Death scene, and place either Adam or Eve on the gravestone.
Panel 2
Use a Love scene and have the Devil claim your deceased’s soul.
What’s something scarier than death? Eternal damnation is probably high on that list.
How did you find this guide? Let me know in the comments.
